Scoring the draft just hours after the final pick is generally frowned upon by more hardcore football fans who know that the actual scoring of the draft is three to four years after the fact. In any case, what the scoring does, to some extent, is capture the national media's reaction to the draft immediately following its completion.
What we do know is that many draft analysts have the Cowboys selecting Tyler Guyton with the 24th pick in their latest mock drafts (NFL.com's Lance Zierlein, The Athletic's Dane Brugler, NFL.com's Peter Schrager, The Ringer's Danny Kelly, and ESPN's Field Yates), just to name a few). The Cowboys took Guyton at No. 29, acquiring an additional third-round pick in the process. Will that affect draft performance?
At least on paper, the Cowboys “won” the trade with the Lions because they used every available draft value technique to advance the deal.
Followers of the Fitzgerald Spielberger chart will be happy to hear that the Cowboys made it there, too, with the excess amount added to a mid-fourth-round pick.
See how 16 different sites graded the Cowboys' first-round performance.
walter soccer They aren't known for their Cowboys-friendly stance, but I liked this pick anyway: A+
This was a sharp move by the Cowboys. With the departure of Troy Fautanu, the Cowboys' top choice at No. 24 overall is Tyler Guyton and Graham Burton. There they could have acquired either, but they would have dropped five spots and acquired more assets, but they still achieved their goal. After last year's debacle, this was a great draft.
NFL.com. Chad Reuter thinks Dallas is a “very good fit.” a
The Cowboys added a third-round pick from Detroit and moved down five draft spots. Guyton's big size (6-7 3/4, 322) and length (34 1/8-inch arms) make him a great fit for Dallas. He spent most of the last two seasons at Oklahoma at right tackle, protecting left-handed quarterback Dillon Gabriel's blindside, but he also plays at left tackle and has the agility to replace departed longtime starter Tyron Smith. It was equipped with It's hard to imagine a better scenario for Dallas.
His colleague Bucky Brooks didn't reveal specific results, but said: “The next great Dallas O-lineman.”
The Cowboys will strengthen their offensive line with players who have the versatility to play either tackle position thanks to their athleticism. Guyton's elite traits could make him the next great Dallas O-lineman.
bleacher report I like how the Cowboys got through the first round. a
All jokes about Jerry Jones' all-in comments aside, the Dallas Cowboys navigated this year's first round in style. They traded down from No. 24 to No. 29, added a third-round pick from the Detroit Lions, and acquired the same player who would have been selected had they stayed at No. 24.
Guyton played right tackle at the University of Oklahoma, but his athleticism suggests he could transition to the blindside. That would keep Tyler Smith at left tackle, where he became an All-Pro.
The Cowboys have a long history of drafting and developing high-end offensive line prospects. Next up is Guyton.
draft kings I also like trading down. a
Guyton was the best OT left and that doesn't matter to him. Of course, he's not at the level of a top OT early on, but he has that upside and is thought to be a solid starter. The Cowboys successfully traded down to acquire him.
sports notes a
I love this selection in Dallas. Trade down, acquire an additional third-round pick, and find value at a position of need. Guyton is expected to go even higher and could slot in as the starting right tackle out of the gate.
touchdown wire I like being named as an immediate starter: a-
Guyton is one of my favorite pass-blocking tackles in this class and has enough on the ball to be an immediate starter or replacement for Tyron Smith in the run game. He will have to solve some problems with power and influence, but he will quickly become Dak Prescott's best friend.
pro football network calls trading down a “smart move.” B+
This is a smart move that will give the team more capital and give them a huge offensive tackle who can play left tackle long-term. Guyton is a massive 6-foot-8, 327-pound man with exceptional athleticism for his size, already possessing excellent technical acumen, and a potential for high growth in his best Football could be ahead of him.
SB Nation: B+
I like this choice in Dallas. Guyton is a former tight end who is a very good athlete and needs a little more improvement in his aim as a run blocker. Going to Dallas is a perfect fit for the Cowboys, who need a replacement for Tyron Smith. Guyton was a right tackle at Oklahoma, but let's assume he moves to the left and Tyler Smith can stay at guard. If Guyton can switch off, things will work out well for Dallas.
athlon sports: B+
This is a solid pick for the Cowboys, who take a step back to gain more draft capital and still address challenges along the offensive line with high upside prospects. Guyton has a nice combination of size, power and athleticism, and his addition gives Dallas flexibility to accommodate Tyler Smith's future placement. An overall win to land a top tackle prospect in a deep class after moving down the board.
for victory: “A project worth working on”: B
This will help you avoid small crises in your offensive line. The departure of Tyron Smith left the Cowboys in a dire situation up front, and it appeared they would be forced to reassign key young players like promising Tyler Smith. Thanks to Guyton, this will no longer be the case. Guyton will allow Dallas to keep Smith on guard and keep defenders in the ground.
Guyton is a little more raw and needs to add that “adult” strength needed to succeed at the next level. But this is a school project worth tackling for the Cowboys just to keep all the players in their natural positions.
sports news: B
The Cowboys may have had Burton and Fautanu more in mind inside, but ultimately it was smart to hire Guyton after parting ways with longtime star left tackle Tyron Smith. It was an action. Beyond his large size, Guyton has proven he has the footwork and agility to play outside defense.
The Athletic “”I likeimmeasurable benefits” Guyton suggests: B
Dallas had two big holes at center and right tackle, and here they filled one on the outside. This is an upward move, as Guyton will start at right tackle and possibly switch to left tackle in time. If he fulfills his potential, he could form a solid tandem with Tyler Smith.
Still a young and developing player, Guyton started 14 games at Oklahoma, 13 at right tackle and one at left tackle, before declaring for the draft. He also started one game at TCU in 2021 as a tight end. Guyton (6-7 1/2, 322) has the physicality needed to be an NFL tackle (34 1/8-inch arms). He may take time, but his benefits are immeasurable.
ringer We also love the benefits of this pick; B
This is a pick I mocked against the Cowboys earlier this week, and it makes a lot of sense for a team looking to fill their offensive line shelves. Guyton has good length and brings top-end athleticism to replace Tyron Smith at left tackle (and also allow Dallas to guard Tyler Smith). There is some risk here, as most of Guyton's college experience has been on the right side. But he has the tools to play on the blind side.
fox sports I like Guyton, but I'm concerned about his consistency. B-
The Cowboys know Guyton better than anyone, having spent his career relatively close to team headquarters, starting his career at TCU before transferring to Oklahoma. He is tall, agile, and versatile and can adapt well to either tackle position. Dallas needed help at left tackle in Tyron Smith, now a member of the New York Jets. Guyton has reliable traits but struggles with consistency, making this a gamble.
yahoo sports: C+
The Cowboys need a left tackle to grow, and at least for now they have a future in Guyton. He still has a little ways to go technically, but the physical tools and frame are there to grow into something long-term. Guyton may be lower down the list than other tackle candidates, but he still has upside.
ESPN's Todd Archer There is no grade, but it provides the following perspectives:
What we're hearing about Guyton: Although he never visited The Star before the draft, the Cowboys met with him at the combine and his pro day. Guyton said he spoke to offensive line coach Mike Solari numerous times and he felt a connection.
“We have a history of having players who execute at a high level at their positions, and there are some traits that have shown us that certainly existed,” said Will, vice president of player personnel. McCray said. “You talk about athleticism, but left tackles are usually more athletic, and this guy is athletic, has a basketball background, and is defensive in nature as well. So the way he plays gives us would also add something.”
I spent the night thinking about it, but what do you think about this selection?
