I enjoy the NFL Scouting Combine and am amazed at how big it has become. But is this as big a problem for teams across the league as the media and fans are making headlines? I think general managers and scouts value game film much more than 40x. Where does the combine really fit into the overall draft process? – John Fellows/Sacramento, California
Nick Eatman: As with everything in life, it depends on who you ask. Some coaches, scouts and GMs value the combine and say it's a must-attend every year. Again, the Cowboys head coach won't be going to the combine this year, so I'm sure he'll be as informed on draft prospects as he has been in years past. I think it's definitely beneficial on the medical side because it gives trainers and doctors the opportunity to evaluate most of these athletes in the same environment. But with Pro Days and his 30 visits, there are other options to meet with players and watch them practice. I think it's an advantage because it's gotten so big, but I don't think it's fatal either. Teams can evaluate players without having to go. Players can be evaluated by their team even if they are not invited.
Mickey: The NFL Combine is more than just running and jumping. First, it's an opportunity to see how well the players perform under the pressure of bright lights. Next, let's talk about the interactions between players and team members during interviews. As you say, game video is the ultimate, but what goes on during interviews at the combine and pro visits can go a long way in determining how a player will fit into a particular franchise and their football acumen. Additionally, if a player is not a first- or second-day draft prospect, this is an opportunity for some attention to focus on lesser-known players and potentially generate interest. And, just like in any professional field, you can judge your team's character by how diligently they prepare for job interviews.
